Ticket #1140 (new defect)

Opened 1 year ago

Last modified 9 months ago

mozilla-plugin completely fails in firefox

Reported by: Metsf1 Assigned to:
Priority: normal Milestone: Bugs paradize
Component: Mozilla plugin Version: 0.8.6a
Severity: normal Keywords:
Cc: Platform(s): Linux
Difficulty: unknown Work status: Not started

Description

The vlc mozilla plugin completely fails to work in firefox. Whenever a page with media is displayed, the plugin says "No Video" or "No Audio". This is not a problem with VLC itself. If you take the media link from the page and load it in the standalone VLC player, it plays perfectly. I tested several websites, including the BBC and CNN, and all the difficult formats (streaming real audio and video and windows media) and had the same result. It seems that this problem is quite widespread and critical. There is a forum topic dedicated to it here (http://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?t=31052) where nobody can get the plugin to work, which is why this ticket is being created.

Change History

(in reply to: ↑ description ) 04/01/07 02:43:58 changed by gjm

I am seeing what looks like the same behaviour in Windows, so either my setup is messed up or this isn't a Linux-specific problem. More precisely: I'm running Firefox 2.0.0.3 on WinXP SP2, using VLC 0.8.6a. Pointing my browser at an Ogg Vorbis file (served with content-type application/ogg, content-disposition inline, proposed filename ending with ".ogg") produces a page that's entirely black except that it says "(no video)" in the middle. (Yes, "video", even though the file in question is actually an audio file.) This isn't a transient thing; it isn't just waiting a while to download enough of the file and then recovering.

If I don't install the Firefox plugin, then pointing my browser at the same file launches the standalone VLC application, which plays the file with no difficulty at all.

04/01/07 02:56:39 changed by gjm

Just to add: uninstalling 0.8.6a and installing 0.8.5 instead makes it work. (At least partly; the music plays, and I have a blank white window with no sign of any controls. I don't know whether the plugin is meant to have any features beyond just playing the media it's given, or whether were were meant to be some controls to fiddle with. If the latter, then something isn't quite right for me still.) So, anyway, this seems to be a regression relative to 0.8.5. I haven't tried 0.8.6.

04/01/07 03:25:47 changed by gjm

Hmm, OK, so it seems that to get any controls I need to write the Javascript myself. So I did, and now Firefox crashes when I view the page with those controls on, and since trying that I now find that the plugin seems to be misbehaving in all sorts of other ways even without any Javascript (e.g., not playing anything, making Firefox crash, ...). This is all with the version 0.8.5 plugin and it seems that things have changed somewhat since then (as witness the fact that the 0.8.6a plugin simply doesn't work :-) ), so it's probably at most marginally relevant.

04/15/07 11:20:29 changed by courmisch

  • keywords deleted.
  • milestone set to Bugs paradize.

12/21/07 21:19:15 changed by funman

  • priority changed from high to normal.
  • severity changed from blocker to normal.